unconscious operating system

CEO Coaching: What You’re Team Won’t Tell You


By Jeff Matlow · Executive Coach · Published October 27, 2026

You’ve got a big problem as CEO.

Sure, you’re the one to run the company. You get to make the big decisions and set the direction for the organization.

The problem is that you’re most likely the last person in the company to find out what’s actually happening.

Think about that for a second.

The person making the most important decisions may be getting the least honest information.

And that, my friend, is one of the reasons CEO coaching exists.

What is CEO Coaching?

CEO coaching is a one-on-one working relationship with an experienced coach who helps you understand how your daily decisions define the culture, environment and results of your organization – whether you intend them to or not.

It’s not just about how you manage other people. It’s about how you lead. That includes how you communicate, how you handle conflict and how you make decisions.

I’ve spent 25 years as a CEO and senior leader at companies of every size. I know what it’s like to sit in that chair.

I’ve been coaching leaders from early stage companies to Fortune 500s, and every level in between.

And though they are all different companies with different dynamics and different ways of getting the job done, the problems that make somebody interested in CEO coaching are often the same.

Let me know if any of these sound familiar:

  • The leadership team isn’t fully aligned
  • Communication among teams – or senior leaders – is failing to be effective
  • Company culture is starting to go sideways
  • Revenue growth is slowing down

And for the life of you, you can’t figure out how to fix it.

You know why? Because somewhere along the way, the information getting to the CEO has been edited in order to keep things running smoothly.

Nobody actually decided to hide the truth. They just learned which truths are welcomed and which ones are too uncomfortable to speak out loud.

Now before you call that a communication problem, it’s not. In order to understand that, you have to look at what happens when someone tells you something you don’t want to hear.

What CEO Coaching Actually Addresses

Most CEOs show up to a problem with a desire to fix it.

Fair enough. They’re dealing with real problems and real problems need real solutions.

But the problem the CEO brings into the CEO coaching discussion is the one they know about. The thing that’s harder to spot is their behavioral patterns that caused the problem in the first place.

I call that the Pattern-Environment Loop.

Your behavior shapes the environment around you. Then that environment reinforces your behavior. When you keep going around that loop enough times, it just gets justified as “how this company works.”

Let me give you an example:

You avoid conflict. You don’t address problems until they become crises. So your team has learned that bringing you bad news makes them look bad. So they wait. They stop telling you bad news right away. And by the time you hear about it, you’re wondering why nobody told you sooner.

OK, here’s another one.

You involve yourself in every important decision. Naturally, your team will start routing everything through you since they know you’re going to decide anyway. Then you complain that nobody takes initiative. Meanwhile, taking initiative means doing work you might tear apart anyway.

Alright, alright, one more.

You’re used to being the smartest person in the room. You have an answer before everyone else has even finished thinking. Eventually, they stop trying to come up with solutions themselves. Then you wonder why you’re the only one with ideas.

Do you see the problem? Do you now understand how your behavior can create an environment that changes the way your team acts?

From your point of view, you’re just keeping the peace. You’re helping people get to the solution faster.

But from everyone else’s perspective, you’re teaching them how to work around you.

That’s where CEO coaching comes in. Because nobody else is going to bring up those behaviors you’re doing that are making other people’s jobs more difficult. After all, you’re the boss. You can fire them. It takes somebody else, like a coach (maybe like Jeff Matlow), to help you see your behavior from a different perspective.

And if you’re the entrepreneur that built the company, your behavior may be the reason why the company got off the ground in the first place. That’s where founder coaching can also become useful – it’s just like CEO coaching, but with an understanding into the nuance of the entrepreneurial mind.

CEO Coaching vs. Executive Coaching

People use these terms interchangeably. Sure, there’s overlap between CEO Coaching and Executive Coaching. But the very nature of the role – CEO vs non-CEO – is where the two diverge.

Executive coaching helps senior leaders understand how their behavior affects their decisions and the people around them. That might mean a VP, a C-suite leader, or a director preparing for a bigger role.

CEO coaching deals with what happens when your behavior sets the conditions for the entire company.

A VP who can’t delegate can clog up a department.

A CEO who can’t delegate can become the bottleneck for an entire company.

Same behavior. Much bigger issue.

There are also other elements inherent to the CEO role that other roles don’t share. There’s the isolation. The board relationship. The separation from what you hear and what is actually happening.

You can have a calendar full of meetings and still have nobody with whom you can have an honest conversation about the decision keeping you awake.

It’s why, as you explore CEO coaching, I’d look for someone who has operated at a level close to yours. Someone who understands what it feels like to make a high-stakes decision with little information and have to live with what happens next.

You need more than an interesting conversation about leadership. You need someone who can help you see what you’re doing while you’re actually doing it.

When CEO Coaching Makes Sense

You don’t need to wait until the company is on fire to consider CEO coaching. In fact, you don’t even need to smell smoke.

Here are four situations I’d consider as triggers to explore CEO coaching.

You’re not getting honest feedback

Sure, the meetings are going smoothly, and your ideas get a surprisingly enthusiastic response.

But something feels off.

Maybe you’re on a roll of being right all the time. Or maybe people have figured out that agreeing with you is a heckuva lot easier than telling you the truth.

CEO coaching is the place to understand what is actually happening. A good coach should be able to challenge your version of events. Even when you fully believe you’re right.

Especially then.

The same problem keeps coming back

If you’re having the same damn conversation with the same damn people but, still, nothing changes – then something needs to change.

As Albert Einstein said, “you can’t solve a problem with the same mind that created it.”

The commonality between all of the problems you’re having is that you’re involved in every one of them. You think you’re the one trying to solve the problem, but what if you’re actually the one perpetuating it?

That doesn’t mean everything is your fault. But it does mean you have to look at the problems differently. Perhaps you are doing something that keeps allowing, or rewarding, the behavior you say you’re trying to stop.

It’s hard to see that pattern on your own. And it’s really hard to see it when you’re not getting feedback (see situation #1 above).

You’re in a transition

Maybe you’ve taken on a new CEO role. Or you’re integrating an acquisition. Maybe you’ve raised a round of funding or the company has grown past the stage where you feel as comfortable as you did before.

There are milestone moments where CEO coaching can become much more useful than you can even imagine – especially when you’re making decisions that are hard to undo later. “Most decisions are just a first date“ is worth a read before you commit to one.

The company is growing, but you’re not sure you are

I’ve seen this before – in fact, I’ve experienced it first hand: Revenue is up, the team is getting bigger but still, for some reason you can’t put your finger on, something still doesn’t feel right.

Are you working harder to keep everything on track?

Do you feel like it’s a house of cards that could all crumble if you make the wrong move?

The way you operate may have made sense when the company was smaller. It may not make the most sense now.

CEO coaching helps you better understand what the company needs from you today, and what you’re still doing only because it worked five years ago.

How CEO Coaching Works

Most CEO coaching engagements run six to twelve months. The details vary, but the work generally follows three phases.

1. Figure out what’s actually happening

We start with what’s happening today.

  • What are your goals?
  • What is getting in the way of achieving those goals?
  • What challenges are you struggling with that you are having trouble resolving?

We try to understand what’s holding you back or what behavior is limiting the effectiveness of others.

In the first sessions, we clearly define the internal and external obstacles in the way of achieving your goals.

I won’t lie, it can sometimes be uncomfortable.

But you’ll get meaningful insight and understanding in as early as one phone call.

2. Work on the decisions you’re making now

CEO coaching then becomes a secret guide to help you navigate the day-to-day decisions in your work life. Think of me like a work-related Tinkerbell who is giving you guidance when you want (or need it). Except without the wings and the antennae on my head.

Maybe it’s helping with an underperforming employee, or a board conversation you’ve been avoiding. Maybe there are strategic decisions that you keep putting off.

Whatever it is, CEO coaching will help you understand how your behavior is influencing the outcome, and it will give you simple solutions to improve.

3. Make the change stick

It’s easy to behave differently when you’re rested and everything is going well.

But the moment stress begins to flare, your default behaviors will come right back as if they never left.

The purpose of CEO coaching is to help you make changes that stick. You’ll learn the patterns you keep repeating, the things that trigger the patterns and the ways to interrupt your default behavior in simple, repeatable ways. In just a few months you can dramatically change the working environment and be on track to achieve your goals.

My goal in CEO coaching is to stop your need for regular CEO coaching.

Where I’d start

If you want to understand your patterns before committing to CEO coaching, I’d start with the Leadership Diagnostic Workshop.

It’s free. It takes 90 minutes. And it’s designed to help you see what you’re subconsciously doing that impacts the behavior of others.

Frequently Asked Questions About CEO Coaching

Q: What is CEO coaching?
CEO coaching is a one-on-one working relationship with an experienced coach who helps you understand how your daily decisions define the culture, environment and results of your organization – whether you intend them to or not. The coach helps you examine how you lead, using the situations you’re dealing with now.

Q: What’s the difference between CEO coaching and executive coaching?
Executive coaching works with senior leaders across different roles. CEO coaching focuses on the person at the top. The work overlaps, but a CEO’s behavior can shape the whole organization. Add the board relationship, the isolation, and the difficulty of getting honest feedback, and the context changes considerably. CEO coaching needs to account for these nuanced realities that come with the CEO role.

Q: Do I need CEO coaching or executive coaching?
If you’re the CEO, look for an engagement built around the demands of that role. Your decisions, your board relationship, and your patterns have consequences across the company. If you’re a senior leader below the CEO level, executive coaching (or even leadership coaching) is usually the more natural fit. Either way, look at the coach’s experience and approach, not just the label on their website.

Q: How do I know if I need CEO coaching?
Start with two questions. Who tells you when you’re wrong? And what behavior keeps happening despite everything you’ve done to try and fix it? If the first answer is “almost nobody” and the second answer came to mind immediately, you have something that’s absolutely worthy of CEO coaching. When you’re stuck inside the pickle jar, you can’t read the label on the outside. CEO coaching helps you understand all the things you can’t see from your perspective.

Q: What should I look for in a CEO coach?
Look for someone who has operated at a level close to yours and understands decisions with real consequences. Then pay attention to whether they’re willing to challenge you. Do they question your assumptions? Can they help you see your part in the problem? If every session ends with confirmation that you were right all along, you may be paying a lot of money for agreement. Might as well just flush those funds down the toilet.

Q: How long does CEO coaching take?
Most engagements run six to twelve months. First, you identify what’s driving the problem. Then you work on real decisions and change the behaviors keeping it alive. Finally, you do the things that make the new behavior stick. Some CEOs continue with lighter check-ins afterward. The goal is for you to recognize and address your patterns with less help over time.

Related articles:


Jeff Matlow is a leadership coach, mentor and 3x entrepreneur who helps senior leaders spot the unconscious patterns keeping their teams dependent on them – then redesign the environment so everyone can actually perform. He’s spent 25+ years working with leaders at Disney, Porsche, Nestlé, and hundreds of high-growth companies. Think Ted Lasso meets Brené Brown meets a Navy SEAL. Learn more about working with Jeff or subscribe to The Best Leadership Newsletter Ever.