Imposter Syndrome In Leadership: What’s Actually Going On

Reading time: 7 minutes

You’ve made it.
Congratulations.

You have the title. The team. The salary that would have seemed like science fiction to your 25-year-old self.
By every measurable standard, you’re exactly where you’re supposed to be, right?

And yet… there’s that voice.
The one inside the mind of imposter syndrome.

The one that shows up in the board meeting right before you speak.
It shows up when someone introduces you with a title that still sounds like it belongs to someone else.
It’s the voice that says things like: It’s only a matter of time before someone realizes I don’t actually know what I’m doing.

That’s imposter syndrome in leadership. And if you’re reading this, there’s a decent chance you know exactly what I’m talking about.

It turns out, I’ve had it too. I see you. I know those voices.
So here’s what I want to tell you about it – and it’s not what you’ve heard before.

—

The Thing Nobody Tells You About Imposter Syndrome

Most advice about imposter syndrome in leadership goes like this: you’re not an imposter. You’ve earned your place. Own it. Believe in yourself.

It’s nice to hear and usually well-intentioned.
It’s also almost completely useless.

Because you know as well as I do, that voice doesn’t respond to logic.
You can recite your credentials all you want. The voice already knows your credentials. It just doesn’t care.

Here’s what the advice-givers miss: imposter syndrome in leadership is not a sign that you don’t belong. In fact, It’s almost always a sign that you do.

The research on this is remarkably consistent – the people most likely to experience imposter syndrome are high achievers, conscientious people, and people who care a lot about doing their job well.

The leaders who never feel like imposters are usually one of 2 things: overly confident in a way that borders on delusion, or genuinely clueless of how much they don’t know.

Neither one of those is a compliment, in case you were wondering.

The imposter syndrome voice, annoying as it may be, has an important role. It shows up when you know enough to understand the gap between where you are and where you could be. It’s the voice of a person inside you that’s paying attention.

The problem isn’t the voice.
The problem is what you do to make it stop.

—

How Imposter Syndrome in Leadership Actually Hurts You

You’re probably like me – when the voice tells you that you’re not enough, you do things to try and prove it wrong.
Not consciously. Not deliberately. But the behavior is remarkably predictable.

I didn’t realize I did these things until well after I learned to control my imposter syndrome. In the hopes of helping you avoid becoming like me, i’m going to tell you the behaviors now.

You overwork. If you just put in more hours, know more things, prepare more thoroughly, maybe the voice will shut up. So you work until 11pm. You read every report. You prep for meetings like you’re studying for the Bar exam. You’re exhausted. But the voice isn’t. It’s still there in your head reminding you that you’re an imposter. It’s whispering in your ear sweet-nothings of being a perfectionist leader.

You over-explain. Imposter syndrome in leadership is marked by a tendency to talk too much in meetings. Not because you’re arrogant – because you’re trying to prove to people how competent you are. I hate to break it to you, but the result is usually the opposite. Long explanations are a warning sign of uncertainty. And the people you’re trying to impress see right through it.

You avoid the things you’re not already good at. The voice is loudest when you’re getting outside your comfort zone. Quieting the voice is easy – you just avoid getting out of your comfort zone, right? You delegate the things that will make people realize you don’t know what you’re doing. You stay in your lanes. Unfortunately, the end result is that your growth stops exactly where you need it the most.

You don’t ask for help. Asking for help feels like you’d be admitting the voice was right. You have no clue what you’re doing and everybody is going to laugh at you. So you figure it out alone, even when you shouldn’t. You make worse decisions and take longer to make them. And you feel more isolated, which feeds the voice, which makes you feel more isolated. Welcome to the world of imposter syndrome in leadership.

You need to know that none of this is weakness. All of it is completely understandable. And all of it, as it compounds over time, creates the exact leadership problems that imposter syndrome was afraid you’d make in the first place.

It’s a self-fulfilling prophecy.

The thing you feared becomes real – not because you were actually an imposter, but because the behaviors you used to silence the voice of imposter syndrome is exactly what led to the outcomes you were afraid of.

I call this the Imposter Loop. And once you can see it, you can’t unsee it.

—

Why Imposter Syndrome Hits Leaders Harder Than Most

Imposter syndrome in leadership has a specific quality that makes it more intense than it might be in other roles.

The higher you rise in your career, the less feedback you get. And the less feedback you get, the more leadership blind spots you have. At the same time, your team needs you to project confidence, your board wants the polished version and your peers are competing with you for attention.

Nobody in your professional life has an incentive to tell you that you’re doing well – or even to tell you where you’re actually falling short.
That feedback loop you had when you were in a more junior role – it suddenly breaks.

So the voice in your head fills the vacuum. In the absence of honest feedback from the outside, your internal critic screams louder. It’s not that your imposter syndrome is worse than other people’s – it’s that the conditions of leadership give it more space to be heard.

And this is why all those people who say things like, “you’re great, just believe in yourself” have no idea what they’re talking about.
The voice isn’t irrational. It’s responding to a real gap in information. After all, you don’t know how you’re actually doing in your job, so your brain fills that gap with the worst-case hypothesis.

The fix isn’t confidence.
The fix is honest information.

—

What Imposter Syndrome in Leadership Is Actually Telling You

Here’s the reframe I want to give you.

Imposter syndrome isn’t a flaw to fix. It’s information to interpret.

When the voice shows up, it’s pointing at something real – not your inadequacy, but your awareness. You know your role is hard. You know the stakes are high. You know you’re still learning things. That awareness is a feature, not a bug.

The leaders who I’m most concerned about are the ones with no imposter syndrome at all. They’ve gotten comfortable with not knowing things and, in doing so, they’ve confused confidence with competence.

Your imposter syndrome means you haven’t done that. It means you’re still paying attention.
That’s a good thing.

What you need isn’t less self-doubt. What you need is a better relationship with your self-doubt – one where the voice informs your judgment instead of running your behavior.

The difference between a leader who’s limited by imposter syndrome and one who’s made peace with it is almost never about credentials or experience. It’s about self-awareness. Specifically, the ability to hear the voice, acknowledge what it’s talking about, and then make a deliberate choice instead of a reactive one.

—

What To Do With It

You’re not going to silence the imposter syndrome voice permanently. I haven’t and I’ve yet to met a self-aware leader who has. Frankly, you probably shouldn’t want to – a little healthy self-doubt is one of the things that gives you your edge over others.

What you can do is stop letting that voice run your behavior from the background.

That means getting honest about the Imposter Loop in your own leadership.

  • Where are you overworking to compensate?
  • Where are you avoiding feedback because it might confirm what the voice is saying?
  • Where are you not asking for help you genuinely need?

Those aren’t rhetorical questions. They’re the actual diagnostic. And the answers are usually sitting right below the surface of your daily thinking. They’re just waiting for someone to ask.

You’re welcome.

The people I work with who’ve made the most progress with imposter syndrome in leadership aren’t the ones who learned to believe in themselves more. They’re the ones who got clear on what the voice was actually responding to – and addressed that, rather than trying to outrun it.

If that’s the work you’re ready to do, the Leadership Diagnostic Workshop is a good place to start. It’s specifically designed to surface the patterns running in your blind spot – including the ones that imposter syndrome has been pointing at all along.

Related Articles

Jeff Matlow is a leadership coach and 3x entrepreneur who helps senior leaders spot the unconscious patterns keeping their teams dependent on them – then redesign the environment so everyone can actually perform. He’s spent 25+ years working with leaders at Disney, Porsche, Nestlé, and hundreds of high-growth companies. Think Ted Lasso meets Brené Brown meets a Navy SEAL. Learn more about working with Jeff or subscribe to The Best Leadership Newsletter Ever.